Treat yourself to award-winning, indulgent all-natural peanut butters that are as good for you as they are delicious. You're supporting a small Kiwi business that gives back to communities and says no to plastic waste.
Ensure that all people enjoy health, justice and prosperity.
Support local businesses at home and abroad
You're supporting a small family business operating on New Zealand's Hibiscus Coast, investing in local employment.
Reuse, repair, recycle, share and borrow
Uses recycled glass jars (90% recycled content), FSC-approved paper labels, and cardboard over plastic alternatives.
Waste less food and use leftovers
When switching between flavours, they bottle excess product and donate it to food banks rather than waste it.
Learn about climate solutions
Uses the Toitū Carbon Assess Tool to measure their carbon footprint and has achieved carbon-neutral status.
Details
Forty Thieves brings you a collection of artisan peanut butters, each crafted with premium New Zealand peanuts and creative flavour combinations.
Available in three indulgent varieties: the rich decadence of Chocolate Fudge, the nostalgic warmth of Cinnamon Donut, or the festive spice of Gingerbread Cookie.
Every jar is made with simple, natural ingredients - no palm oil, no artificial nasties - just pure peanut goodness. Choose your favourite flavour and spread the love, one spoonful at a time.
Jar size 290g.
Flavours
Chocolate Fudge Peanut Butter Mr. Smuggles™ and his band of thieves have smuggled in the goodness of cashews & peanuts into this creamy chocolate nut butter. Crushed on the sunny Hibiscus Coast of New Zealand.
Even the fussiest little eaters deserve real nutrition every day and in their lunch boxes. Enjoy the same level of sweetness, rich flavour and super creamy texture as chocolate spreads you might know from Europe while benefiting from 68% nuts, 3.6g of sugar per serve and a clean ingredient list.
Cinnamon Donut Peanut Butter Mr. Smuggles™ and his band of thieves have smuggled in the goodness of almonds, cashews and peanuts into this warm-spiced nut butter. Crushed on the sunny Hibiscus Coast of New Zealand.
Even the fussiest little eaters deserve real nutrition every day and in their lunch boxes. Enjoy the same level of sweetness, rich flavour and super creamy texture as sweet biscuit spreads you might know from Europe while benefiting from 82% nuts, 2.7g of sugar per serve and a clean ingredient list.
Gingerbread Cookie Peanut Butter Mr. Smuggles™️ and his band of thieves have smuggled Christmas into a jar! Enjoy flavours of spiced gingerbread with roasted peanuts, almonds and cashews. Crushed on the sunny Hibiscus Coast of New Zealand. Stashed with 75% whole nuts, just 2.3g sugar per serving, a clean ingredient list and a sprinkle of holiday cheer!
